Exploring the Role of Participatory Democracy in Trade Unions: A Look at Policy Influence and Decision-Making Processes

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by the author(s) do not represent the official position of Barbados TODAY.

By Dennis De Peiza

Participatory democracy is known to be practised within civil society organisations. Trade unions as representatives of the interests of workers, aiming to safeguard their rights and improve their working conditions, associate themselves with democratic principles. These principles are often reflected in the national constitution and international labour standards. Heading the list of the democratic principles, would be citizens’ participation and equality. This flows naturally with the features of democracy, which include freedom of assembly, freedom of association, freedom of religion and speech, voting rights and freedom from unwarranted governmental deprivation of the right to life and liberty.

Participatory democracy is about citizens being able to participate individually and directly in political decisions and the formulation of policies that affect their lives, rather than this being done through their elected political representatives. It is correct to state that trade unions are not political organisations, but it is evident that they cannot divorce themselves from being able to influence policymaking, political actions and decisions. It is through their ability to lobby that they are able to influence the decision-making process. The positions take directions followed by the trade union leadership and are often guided by the directive of the membership, following being engaged in the process of consultation.

The mandate of the membership is generally supported by a majority vote.

The beauty of participatory democracy is that it allows for the trade union membership, through the means of their individual vote, to arrive at a majority decision on a matter which the leadership is obligated to follow, implement or discharge. In the trade union management structure, the executive committee, board or council is entrusted with decision-making.

However, there are limitations imposed, as unilateral decision-making can easily be overturned by the membership through the calling of a special general meeting, at which the matter is discussed and a directive or mandate is issued by the membership.

It can be argued that participatory democracy is best suited to the operations of trade unions. It allows the members to maintain control, rather than surrendering the total decision-making process into the hands of elected officials. When compared with representative democracy, where there is political representation, the difference comes when the members of a constituency elect an individual to specifically attend to their interests.